| The first lie | ![]() |
A couple of weeks ago, Siddhu was raiding the kitchen, as he usually does when he gets bored. It has become his obsession to pour some flour, mix it with egg and oil, and attempt to make pancakes - he can almost fix a pancake for himself now, just doesn't dare light the stove because he knows that is hot and can hurt him. This time around, I was in the backyard, and Pramila was working on her computer. As he climbed the kitchen counter and was sifting through the cabinet, he dropped a box of cereal on the floor, with cereal pouring out. Pramila heard the noise and came out, asked him in her exasperated tone "Siddhu, who did this?" expecting him to give his usual reply of "Clean up, why did you do it?" He has the habit of repeating or mimicking what the other person would say in that circumstance, rather than make up his own answer.
But he surprised her this time. Siddhu looked at her, with a mischevious smile, "Appa did it". Pramila could not believe it - she called me and asked me with an accusing tone "Did you really do this?" I said "No, I wasn't even here". She could still not trust that our son had figured out how to lie! She asked Siddhu "Who is going to clean it up now?" and he answered "Appa will clean it". She gave him a hug, and we celebrated his first lie that evening. In its own way, this feels like a major triumph for us - autistic kids are so literal-minded that lying is a major effort.
But he surprised her this time. Siddhu looked at her, with a mischevious smile, "Appa did it". Pramila could not believe it - she called me and asked me with an accusing tone "Did you really do this?" I said "No, I wasn't even here". She could still not trust that our son had figured out how to lie! She asked Siddhu "Who is going to clean it up now?" and he answered "Appa will clean it". She gave him a hug, and we celebrated his first lie that evening. In its own way, this feels like a major triumph for us - autistic kids are so literal-minded that lying is a major effort.
Comments:
Comment from:
swaminathan [Member]
Hi Svembu
It is really great news and only parent of an ASD kid can realise the importance. On the whole ASD kids are so naive that they do not have the concept of lying (I was reading in the net once about a teacher asking a kid- ASD or aspergers- why he was behaving so badly, and he calmly said he was doing it on purpose).
So another myth exploded I guess. Ironically congrats on the first corruption of mind.
Thanks for sharing for it raises hopes for us too
Regards
Swaminathan
It is really great news and only parent of an ASD kid can realise the importance. On the whole ASD kids are so naive that they do not have the concept of lying (I was reading in the net once about a teacher asking a kid- ASD or aspergers- why he was behaving so badly, and he calmly said he was doing it on purpose).
So another myth exploded I guess. Ironically congrats on the first corruption of mind.
Thanks for sharing for it raises hopes for us too
Regards
Swaminathan
Comment from:
raghu [Member]
Netra did something similar sometime back. She loved to get on the bed (near a cupbord), prop herself into the cupboard shelf and pick up bangles and stuff. My wife would often reproach her since N would mess up the shelf and could also fall down and hurt herself.
On one occassion, the door was closed and my wife opened it and found that Netra was upto the same stuff. When she was asked why she had closed the door, Netra replied, "You scold me if you catch me doing this...so I closed the door"
Raghu
On one occassion, the door was closed and my wife opened it and found that Netra was upto the same stuff. When she was asked why she had closed the door, Netra replied, "You scold me if you catch me doing this...so I closed the door"
Raghu
Comment from:
malini [Member]
My son Akhil, has the habit of thumb sucking. And i keep worrying about it as to his teeth might become protruding, or he might get addicted to that habbit etc., But when i read these kinds of posts where parents are in such worries and expectations from their children, Instaneously I feel grateful to God rather than to complain with what is given... Sridhar, I just wish and pray your son gets well soon. Jaya.
Comment from:
srikrishnan [Visitor]
Sridhar great find..
Malini..
There is nothing to worry about thumb sukking. You can see people in your day to day life and how many of their teeth gets protruded. do you know, my kid managed to put all her 10 fingers and sucks.
Malini..
There is nothing to worry about thumb sukking. You can see people in your day to day life and how many of their teeth gets protruded. do you know, my kid managed to put all her 10 fingers and sucks.
Comment from:
SRK [Visitor]
Good to see.
Congrats on the first lie !
Hope he learns more from his father :-
Congrats on the first lie !
Hope he learns more from his father :-
Comment from:
Prasad [Visitor]
· http://coolprasad.blogspot.com
That's a touching episode Sridhar.
Comment from:
Badrinath.V.S [Visitor]
· http://badrinath.blogspot.com
Sridhar,
Very touching, I can imagine how happy you and your wife would have felt. Congrads and best wishes for sidhu's speedy recovery.
happy for you
regards,
--Badri--
Very touching, I can imagine how happy you and your wife would have felt. Congrads and best wishes for sidhu's speedy recovery.
happy for you
regards,
--Badri--
Comment from:
ajai [Visitor]
Hi
Reminded me of another parent here in bangalore who called me up all excited, to say that his son had told his first lie that day. Boy, the milestones we look for, on the journey!It sure must be a huge moment for all.
What do we do with Sally and Ann now and the whole Theory of Mind thingy, that they told us our children would not be able to comprehend?
Ajai
Reminded me of another parent here in bangalore who called me up all excited, to say that his son had told his first lie that day. Boy, the milestones we look for, on the journey!It sure must be a huge moment for all.
What do we do with Sally and Ann now and the whole Theory of Mind thingy, that they told us our children would not be able to comprehend?
Ajai
Comment from:
Dheepa [Visitor]
Hi
Too cute of Siddhu !!!
Happy to knw he is progressing
Cheers
Dheepa
Too cute of Siddhu !!!
Happy to knw he is progressing
Cheers
Dheepa
Comment from:
autism911 [Member]
Your post reminded me of the first time one of my students with ASD told a lie and my classroom staff and I were so happy! It is a major achievement. Celebrate.
Comment from:
Sudha [Visitor]
Sridhar,
Though I read this after a year, certainly I trust your son had come a long way now.
We pray for your son's speedy recovery.
Regards,
Sudha
Though I read this after a year, certainly I trust your son had come a long way now.
We pray for your son's speedy recovery.
Regards,
Sudha
Comment from:
Rekha [Visitor]
So touching! got goosebumps as i read through this post!
I can imagine how happy you both would have felt at that moment :)
Good luck to Siddhu for a speedy recovery!
-Rekha
I can imagine how happy you both would have felt at that moment :)
Good luck to Siddhu for a speedy recovery!
-Rekha
Comment from:
Radha [Visitor]
Read about Siddhu in "India Abroad." Loved it. Now, Appa gets to be blamed in our house too for everything! It will be great if I can get a hold of Sridhar or Pramilla via my email. Thanks for sharing.
Comment from:
Vimala [Visitor]
I read about Sridhar Vembu in Sramana Mitra's book recently. I guess this Sridhar Vembu is the same person.
There was one thing that you do attracted me a lot. Your way of finding people without qualifications and making them to contribute to cutting edge engineering work. Superb.
While googling to find more about your recruitment, I came across this blog. Very touchy and thanks for sharing.
There was one thing that you do attracted me a lot. Your way of finding people without qualifications and making them to contribute to cutting edge engineering work. Superb.
While googling to find more about your recruitment, I came across this blog. Very touchy and thanks for sharing.
Comment from:
Solilo [Visitor]
· http://mesoliloquy.wordpress.com
Madhu of Indimag left this link on my latest post and I got an opportunity to read about your amazing child.
Kudos to him and your family!
Kudos to him and your family!
Comment from:
Term Papers [Visitor]
· http://www.ghostpapers.com
superb news ... thanks for informing .




